Some direction symbols not exported as proper FIT course point typesFORUMS HOME SEARCH FORUMS

Total posts in this topic: 18
Showing oldest posts first - Show newest
Sign in to post to this topicSIGN IN

    Page: 
    • 1
  • Photo
    Topic
    Creator
    Lasse Lasse   Friday 16 Sep 2022 18:04:39

    When I prepare my hiking routes with plotaroute, I rely heavily on the directions feature to add waypoints for water, shelter, supermarkets, campsites etc., using symbols to indicate the type of waypoint because this nicely shows up on the map and is also displayed by my Garmin watch.

    With the recent FIT SDK 21.89 release, Garmin has finally added a list of additional course point types that makes this feature even more useful. I was very happy to discover that plotaroute already supports some of them (e.g. campsite, toilet, transport/train station). However there a few missing that I would love to see supported:

    FIT course point (id)  <-> Plotaroute symbol
    store (48)  <-> shop
    rest_area (29) <-> picnic site
    shelter (36)  <-> accommodation could work, but even better would be a new symbol, since shelters are more basic

    I would also propose to map Plotaroute's "water source" to FIT's "water (3)" as it is already the case with "drinking water", since Garmin/FIT doesn't differentiate.

    Thank you!

    PS: Is there an overview of the symbol to FIT course point mappings somewhere? I only found an old thread in the Garmin forum regarding the limited old mappings.

  • Photo
    plotaroute admin   Saturday 17 Sep 2022 11:58:52

    Thanks for that feedback Lasse. We did recently add some new Point Types for FIT files, but we'd need to investigate to see whether any of the ones you suggested can be added.

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Saturday 17 Sep 2022 12:58:30

    "We did recently add some new Point Types for FIT files". This is great. Is it documented somewhere which one you added?

    It would be great if it could be visible when selecting symbols in some way, which ones are supported in fit.

  • Photo
    plotaroute admin   Monday 19 Sep 2022 08:39:00

    Hi Peter,

    All the Plotaroute symbols are supported but most will be mapped to the Generic Point Type, as there isn't another suitable one. This is the current list we have for symbols that don't map as Genric:

    Plotaroute Symbol FIT PointType
    Mountain Summit
    Drinking Water Water
    Food Food
    Warning Danger
    First Aid FirstAid
    Runners Sprint
    Campsite Campsite
    Meeting Point MeetingSpot
    Toilets/Restroom Toilet
    Shower Shower
    Uphill SteepIncline
    Paths Cross Crossing
    Bus Stop, Train Station Transport
    Information Info

    However, if there is a turn at that point in the route, the turn will be used to set the Point Type instead of any symbol selected:

    Plotaroute Turn Arrow FIT PointType
    Left Left
    Right Right
    Straight Straight
    Slight Left SlightLeft
    Sharp Left SharpLeft
    Slight Right SlightRight
    Sharp Right SharpRight
    U Turn UTurn

  • Photo
    Topic
    Creator
    Lasse Lasse   Wednesday 21 Sep 2022 10:49:26

    Thank you for the list of supported FIT course point types, this is very helpful.

    I suggest to add the following mappings to expand the coverage even more:

    Plotaroute Symbol FIT PointType
    Picnic Site RestArea
    Water Source Water
    Shop Store
    Accommodation Shelter

     

  • Photo
    plotaroute admin   Thursday 22 Sep 2022 08:40:19

    Thanks Lasse. We've got to make changes to our download process for a separate bug fix, so we'll see if we can add those in at the same time. 

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Thursday 22 Sep 2022 21:55:00

    My wish list for new FIT file symbol types:

    (Plotaroute symbol -> Fit file course point type)

    [IMAGE REMOVED DUE TO SIZE]

    [IMAGE REMOVED DUE TO SIZE]

    [IMAGE REMOVED DUE TO SIZE]

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Thursday 22 Sep 2022 22:01:29

    And maybe this one:

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Friday 23 Sep 2022 06:15:27

    What do you say about:

  • Photo
    plotaroute admin   Friday 23 Sep 2022 08:22:09

    Just in time Peter! Most of those look straightfoward. Not sure about one or two of them - T for tunnel for example, as people could be using that for other purposes, so displaying a tunnel symbol might not be appropriate. We'll add in as many as we can.

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Friday 23 Sep 2022 09:08:07

    Perfect, thanks.

  • Photo
    plotaroute admin   Friday 23 Sep 2022 09:37:40

    We've just implemented this Peter. Here's the latest list. The "Info" PointType should hopefully now be fixed too.

    Plotaroute Symbol FIT PointType
    Mountain Summit
    Drinking Water Water
    Water Source Water
    Food Food
    Warning Danger
    First Aid FirstAid
    Runners Sprint
    Campsite Campsite
    Meeting Point MeetingSpot
    Toilets/Restroom Toilet
    Shower Shower
    Uphill SteepIncline
    Paths Cross Crossing
    Bus Stop, Train Station Transport
    Information Info
    Picnic Site RestArea
    Shop Store
    Accomodation Shelter
    Stop Alert
    1 FirstCategory
    2 SecondCategory
    3 ThirdCategory
    4 FourthCategory
    Fuel/Gas Service
    Map Pin DistanceMarker
    Marker DistanceMarker
    Checkpoint Checkpoint
    Viewpoint Overlook
    Look Out Overlook
    Photo Point Overlook
    Fence/Gate Obstacle
    Downhill Valley
  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Friday 23 Sep 2022 10:58:31

    Thanks,

    Did you see the diff on dist markers beween fit type 30 and 34?

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Sunday 25 Sep 2022 18:21:00

    This is so great!

    I did some testing on a long run today. Not all of the new ones are working for me. I will look into it further, but this is how the symbols are visualized in the up-ahead feature on my Garmin Epix.

    [IMAGE REMOVED DUE TO SIZE]

  • Photo
    plotaroute admin   Monday 26 Sep 2022 09:19:00

    Thanks Peter, that's very interesting to see the Epix symbols. We'll look into the ones that aren't working.

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Tuesday 27 Sep 2022 23:04:00

    Thank you so much. This is what it looks like now from your list:

    [IMAGE REMOVED DUE TO SIZE]

    [IMAGE REMOVED DUE TO SIZE]

  • Photo
    plotaroute admin   Wednesday 28 Sep 2022 09:05:17

    That's great, thanks Peter.

  • Photo
    Topic
    Creator
    Lasse Lasse   Wednesday 05 Oct 2022 17:12:39

    I have successfully verified the list of supported types when downloading a FIT file, in the FIT file itself, and using the FIT SDK in the Android app I'm working on.

    Thank you so much for the prompt implementation and Peter for testing and visualization! Simply amazing.

    In terms of Garmin device support, I discovered that my Fenix 6s Pro (v23.00) does not display symbols for the new course point types introduced this year with the Fenix 7. (I will raise this with Garmin, hopefully they'll add support to a future firmware version.) Still, the new expanded support by plotaroute is very valuable for me, since I'm working on a CIQ app that displays waypoints and here I support all course point types.

Page: 
  • 1